How to recognize it: The classic hydrangea with round mophead or flat lacecap flowers in blue, pink, or purple (with color determined by soil pH). Bigleaf blooms in early summer and is by far the most commonly planted hydrangea in American gardens. If you bought a hydrangea at a garden center without paying close attention to the tag, there's a good chance this is what you have.
Pruning verdict: Do not cut back in fall. Those stems standing in your garden right now are already carrying the buds for next summer's flowers. Every stem you remove this fall is a stem that won't bloom next June. This single mistake accounts for more disappointed, bloomless hydrangeas than any other cause and it's completely avoidable once you know what's happening.
When to prune: Right after flowering in early summer, typically June or July, if any shaping is needed. Pruning immediately after bloom gives the plant the rest of the growing season to set new buds on the fresh growth, and those buds will be ready to open the following summer. That's the window. Outside of it, put the pruners away.
What to do in fall instead: Leave the stems completely alone. A light layer of mulch around the base for root protection is all the attention a bigleaf hydrangea needs in fall. Leave the stems, the old flowers, the whole structure standing.
That said, there are exceptions to every rule. Every few years even my bigleaf and mountain hydrangeas start to outgrow their space. When that happens, I’ll cut them back hard in the fall, sometimes all the way to the ground, knowing full well I’m giving up the first flush of blooms the following season. The plant comes back a more manageable size, puts on new growth, and I can still enjoy the blooms later in the season.